As voting is soon to begin, I believe that the greatest hotels in a resort are the Beach and Yachtt club. It has everything you would want in a Disney resort: top notch food, greatest pool in any Disney resort, character breakfast to rival the parks, closeness to EPCOT, and never forget the Kitchen Sink!
My favourite theme park hotel, Saratoga Springs, isn't on the hotel listings page. It's beautiful, comfortable, relatively economical, and convenient. What gives?
Also, for everyone else, please remember that you can rate any of the hotels listing on our "Hotel Reviews" page (link's at the top of any page, in the gold navigation bar.) The ones I've listed in this post are simply the ones currently near the top for highest average reader ratings. Others could pass them, if enough people rate them up.