I'd actually put Sesame Street second because I thought the film was pretty funny.
For whatever reason, Shrek doesn't really do much for me though the anti-Disney jokes are funny and the moving chairs are cool.
ITTBAB is my favorite of this bunch. It illicits a wider variety of audience responses than any other 4D show I have seen. I especially love the way unsuspecting and unprepared parents are left struggling to curtail the terrified screams of their younglings! Why do parents just assume because something is Disney it is suitable for all ages? Real parents do their research ahead of time, not in the field!
Incidentally, I thought the new Sesame Street show replaced Pirates 4D at BG TAMPA a while back? Yay or nay?
In all honesty, probably both shows need to go, and a new high-quality adventure should be produced.