Readers' Opinions

From 76.178.189.151 on July 28, 2013 at 9:24 PM
I've had it before up here in Northern Idaho. The local ACE Hardware carries it. It's okay, not the best, I didn't feel like it tasted like Uni's Butterbeer, but that's just me.
From 67.78.144.130 on July 29, 2013 at 8:13 AM
I dunno about Butterbeer in a bottle. But I can say emphatically that Virgil's is the very best root beer I've ever tasted. It used to be imported into the U.S. from England before Reeds bought the rights to make it here.

What makes it so great? It's possible to taste individual flavors like Vanilla, Liquorice and Mint in the beverage -- something the mass produced brands like A&W did away with long ago in favor of artifical flavorings.

- Brian

From 204.128.192.32 on July 29, 2013 at 9:08 AM
Last time I was over there (about a month ago), Galco's Old World Grocery had Flying Cauldron soda.

We bought a bottle, but haven't tried it yet.

From 204.128.192.31 on July 29, 2013 at 3:37 PM
You can also buy these at a place called "Rocket Fizz" here in California. I find it to be quite good and close to the real thing, aside from the delicious foam of course. I recommend it.
From Tony Perkins on July 30, 2013 at 5:58 AM
Virgil's makes absolutely the best sodas on the planet. After you try their stuff, you'll never go back to Pepsi and Coke garbage again. Try the Black Cherry Soda, it's fantastic. You can taste the natural flavors of their sodas, and not the corn syrup and other trash put into the mass market brands.
From 184.90.151.249 on July 31, 2013 at 8:09 AM
Much to my surprise, a local bar here (just north of Orlando) stocks this stuff, and it is delicious. It tastes VERY similar to the real thing. I haven't tried it with ice cream but that sounds pretty good...
From 74.202.118.163 on July 31, 2013 at 10:22 AM
When I read your article about Flying Cauldron Butterscotch Beer, I remembered having seen it at a snack kiosk at one of our local malls here on the island of Oahu in Hawaii. Thanks for giving me an excuse to try it and compare it to the real deal that we had at Wizarding World of Harry Potter last summer in Orlando.

My ten-year-old daughter and I really enjoyed Butterbeer, both the frozen and the "cold" versions. Her preference was "Icee-style" as we called it, while I believe I preferred the mug full of creamy, cold-but-not-frozen goodness. Yes, we sprang for the mug.

I think we both agreed that the Flying Cauldron version was kind of pegging the sweetness meter, at least for our taste buds. The cream soda element was much stronger than I remember from the Park, and also, I thought that the original butterbeer had just a touch of a root beer twist to it which was not present at all in the knock-off.

Also, here in Hawaii, they'll hit you up for $3 per bottle! No real surprise there, if you've ever been here or lived here. Everything is more expensive.

All in all, we enjoyed it, and it brought back awesome memories of our day at Universal's Islands of Adventure, but I wouldn't rush back over there to grab another bottle. I suppose if we ever had any reason to have a Harry Potter-themed party, though...

From 172.249.61.163 on August 2, 2013 at 7:09 PM
Out here on the West Coast there is a chain of stores called "Rocket Fizz" that sells this in single bottles, either off the shelf or from a refrigerated cabinet. They also have 6 packs. The are priced about the same as mentioned above. But out here it is named Golden Cauldron but is from the same distributor. I love the stuff and it's the only soda pop I will drink. And a scoop of Vanilla (or Vanilla Bean)ice cream really adds the foam and is really good tasting.