Show Me The Coasters - Part 8

October 31, 2019, 5:04 PM

On Friday, June 21st, the Show Me the Coasters tour set off from Minneapolis, Minnesota. Over the following week, the tour took my friends and I through Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, Missouri, and Iowa, before returning to Minneapolis very late on June 28th. While we were back where we started, the tour was not yet over. A two night stay at the Crowne Plaza Aire near MSP airport would allow for us to check out a couple more parks located in the twin cities. After a dozen previous stops, you might think we'd be tired of parks by now, but Andrew, Rob, and I still had one more Cedar Fair park to conquer.

Show Me The Coasters
Part 8: A Fair, a Town, and a Mall


Saturday was our final day together, as Rob would be departing that evening and Andrew had an early flight out the next morning. Therefore, we decided to spend the day at Valleyfair, the second park in the Cedar Fair chain and the last in the chain I had left to visit. This park opened in 1976 with 20 attractions on 26 acres, and with significant investment has grown to feature 75 rides on 125 acres. While originally one of the crown jewels of the chain, since the early 2000s the park has grown somewhat stagnant as Cedar Fair has focused their capital expansion elsewhere, thus Valleyfair has not installed a major attraction in nearly a decade. For a local, that is a frustrating turn of events, particularly when the nearest park of comparable size is two states away. As a first time visitor, however, I was quite curious to see what the park had to offer.


Before we get to that, I must make a confession. While Valleyfair was the final major park of the tour and was a new park to all of us, this was actually my second visit to the park. On the first day of the tour, Rob's flight was delayed several hours, so I opted to secretly head over to Valleyfair for an hour and attempt to credit run the place. I wound up getting six of seven possible credits before I had to return to the airport, but it gave me an impression of the place.


Knowing what laid in store, I tried my best not to upsell the park, because, well...Valleyfair feels like a park lifted directly out of Roller Coaster Tycoon. Nothing about the park stands out as particularly unique, and with the exception of isolated buildings it is utterly devoid of theming. Attractions are plopped down wherever there's available space, and nothing feels particularly creative in layout or look.


Valleyfair's layout resembles a box and whisker plot oriented roughly east-west, with the entrance located on the eastern end of the box. A midway extends east from this point, and another at the far end of the box dead-ends at the far west corner of the property. Therefore, we decided it was best to approach this park systematically rather than trying to head straight to the headliners. Our first coaster therefore was Steel Venom, located near the entrance in the eastern whisker. This was my last of the five North American Impulse coasters to try, and it felt mostly similar to the others. The ride gets bonus points for still having an operational holding brake on the rear spike, but beyond that there's nothing new or different here. To our surprise, Rob was able to ride this one despite being denied on SFGAm's identical ride...I guess the belts are longer here.


We were planning to hit Wild Thing next, but it was experiencing a minor delay. With super short lines despite it being a Saturday (we didn't encounter a wait over 15 minutes), we headed further west to Mad Mouse. An Arrow mouse identical to the one at Michigan's Adventure, this completed yet another set for me. Unfortunately, heavy trim brakes and a slightly rough ride rendered this a dull coaster not even worthy of a re-ride from Andrew, our resident Arrow fanatic. Plus, due to an incredibly slow loading procedure, we spent about two and a half minutes on the brakes waiting to unload (keep in mind the ride is only a minute and a half).!


Further down the western whisker lies Renegade, Valleyfair's GCI and the last in North America I had left to experience (see a pattern here?). After riding Prowler, I had warned Rob and Andrew that Renegade would be underwhelming, and while Prowler is the better ride Renegade is not far behind. The first half of the layout is GCI's take on an out and back coaster, with a few twists thrown in for good measure. After that, Renegade turns into a pure twister, winding around close to the midway and fitting in well next to one or two western themed buildings. It isn't the longest or most extreme ride out there, but it's a good length and a very good coaster. We ended up with seven rides total on this one, including the last train of the night (which even at 10 P.M. was still somewhat light due to the high latitude).


Excalibur (the one credit I missed on my initial visit) doesn't open until noon, so we were prevented from proceeding further west. Instead, we backtracked to the box and took a ride on Valleyfair's other woodie, High Roller. The largest ride at Valleyfair on opening day, today this ride is more of a family coaster. A fairly smooth out-and-back, the ride contains several trim brakes that rob the layout of airtime. If it was longer or more exciting I likely would have given this multiple rides, but with the longest line amongst the park's coasters one lap was sufficient.


By the time we got off High Roller, Wild Thing had returned to service so we hit that next. This was the last American Morgan I had left to ride (surprise surprise), and it rode very similarly to Mamba just a couple days earlier.


Unlike the other Morgans, Wild Thing actually featured a bit of floater airtime once it got warmed up, but the ride was still on the weaker end of hyper coasters in my book. Still, it was the best steel coaster at the park and worth a few rides given the short wait.


We now had two Arrows remaining before conquering Valleyfair. Since it was closer, we started with Corkscrew. An older Arrow looper (and the last in North America I needed to ride), Valleyfair's Corkscrew was more or less a smoother version of Cedar Point's Corkscrew.


The very short ride features a drop, loop, turn, double corkscrew, and helix in that order. Surprisingly, this is Valleyfair's only inverting coaster to this day. It was okay...not bad, but not great.


Lastly, we turned our attention to Excalibur. Essentially a single tracked version of Cedar Point's Gemini, Excalibur is what happens when you make a mine train into a thrill ride. It was jerky with some abrupt airtime and a very unusual layout, but had just enough good elements to recommend taking it for a spin. Unfortunately I only got one ride on it since this coaster operates very limited hours, but it is certainly the oddest among Valleyfair's collection. And no, it wasn't my last North American Arrow...I've still got a handful I need to hit (including two that didn't quite make the cut for this trip).


The coasters complete, we took another lap of the park to hit a few of the park's non-coaster rides. Most significant among these were a pair of S&S creations: Power Tower and Xtreme Swing. Power Tower is an S&S triple tower, featuring a space shot tower and two turbo drop towers. While not quite as tall as the identically named ride at Cedar Point, the ride is still plenty tall enough to provide a thrill. Next door, Xtreme Swing is a Screamin' Swing just slightly smaller than Cedar Point's Skyhawk and just as intense.


We also checked out Northern Lights, a Disk'O Coaster that some parks count as a roller coaster. I don't count these, but they are still fun rides with a spinning car traversing an extended halfpipe. Lastly, Andrew and I took a ride on Valleyfair's railroad, which was nothing to write home about.


By 2 P.M., we'd completed most of Valleyfair's notable attractions, so we headed out for a bonus park. Located 45 minutes away in nearby St. Paul, Como Town is a small park attached to the much larger Como Park Zoo. If we'd had more time, I would have gladly spent a few hours exploring this zoo and checking out all the animals. Unfortunately, we had just enough time to enter the amusement park and ride Tiger Trax, the park's Zyklon style coaster.


There are some that look down on enthusiasts who seek to ride out of the way credits, particularly when said rides are small stock model coasters. However, occasionally that sort of thing has unexpected rewards. This particular day was one of those. As we approached the coaster, we saw a couple kids walk up the ramp and get turned away. Unfortunately, they were too short to ride without an adult, and neither of the parents wanted to ride. As the tears started, the dad noticed us walking up the ramp and comes running over, asking if the kids can ride with us. In essence, we were borrowed to chaperone the kids on what may have been their first roller coaster (or at least their first full size one). It doesn't matter that the coaster was mediocre, the experience was absolutely memorable, and had we had more time I'm sure the kids would have loved two or three more laps. Sadly, we had to say our goodbyes and head out.


Rob's flight was departing Saturday evening, so we took a detour to drop him off at the Mall of America so he could collect a few last credits before flying back to Virginia. Andrew and I then headed back to Valleyfair, returning around 5 P.M. Once through the gate, we parted ways as I wanted to check out Valleyfair's waterpark and Andrew wanted tons of re-rides. On the way to the waterpark, I stopped by Chickie and Pete's for a sandwich, then got suited up for some wet action.


Valleyfair's Soak City is among the smallest waterparks in the Cedar Fair chain, but still provides enough attractions for a couple hours of fun. I started off with Breaker's Plunge, a nine story free fall slide. I do not get intimidated by slides, but staring down a cliff is always just a tiny bit unnerving. A couple girls in front of me stood at the top of the slide freaking out for about two minutes before stepping aside and allowing me to take the plunge. Unlike older free fall slides, this one was very smooth and provided a short but exciting thrill.


On a lower platform from the same tower was Breaker's Pipeline, the park's trapdoor slide complex. I don't always bother with speed slides (particularly if there's a wait...these were about 20 minutes), but trapdoor slides are among my favorite due to the dropping sensation as the floor pulls away. I did two rides on this one, one to experience the straight drop slides and one for a helix slide.


Next was Panic Falls, the original body slide complex at the waterpark. Riders have their choice of five ways down from the six story platform...two speed slides and three serpentine slides. Having had enough of speed slides, I did two of the three serpentine slides here. Honestly, they were a bit on the dull side, though I attribute that to their age more than anything else.


Lastly, I took a ride down Raging Rapids, Soak City's lone innertube slide. Built into the side of a small hill, Raging Rapids is less a slide and more like a river rapids ride ridden on a single tube. The ride is turbulent, with small drops, obstacles, waterfalls, and a tunnel, but is a lot of fun and very different from modern waterslides. I would have given this a second ride had I reached it earlier, but it was nearing closing time for Soak City and I still had a few coasters I wanted to ride.


Night began its slow descent as I reunited with Andrew outside of Soak City. He'd been spending the last couple hours re-riding his favorite coasters and hitting some flats. We essentially did the same, grabbing multiple rides on Renegade, Steel Venom, and Wild Thing. Eventually, we decided to just camp at Renegade for the rest of the evening, winding up with back row seats on the last train of the night. It was a great way to wrap up the official part of the tour.


Overall, Valleyfair is the best example I can think of when it comes to an average park. There isn't anything wrong with the place, and it is an enjoyable park to spend the day at. However, there's nothing that sets the park above others, and even their top attractions aren't among the best of their type. I'm certainly glad I visited, and would likely stop by for a couple hours if I found myself in Minneapolis again, but there is little reason to travel out of the way for this park unless you're a completionist. Sure, you'll have a fun day, but you can get better coasters, better theming, and better atmosphere at almost any other Cedar Fair park.


Valleyfair Coaster Rankings:

B Tier:

1. Renegade
2. Wild Thing
3. Steel Venom

D Tier:

4. High Roller
5. Excalibur

Credit Tier:

6. Corkscrew
7. Mad Mouse

Upon returning to the hotel, I said goodnight and goodbye to Andrew. He had a morning flight out, and would be taking a shuttle from the hotel to the airport before I woke in the morning. After plenty of non-stop action the past few days, I got caught up on my trip updates and then went to bed.

The next morning, I took advantage of a 10:45 departure and my own room to sleep in. However, the last park of the trip called, so once I was packed I loaded up the car and made the five minute drive to the last park of the trip.

If you've been to Minneapolis (or even if you haven't), you're most likely familiar with their largest tourist attraction: the Mall of America. When I picked up the rental car, the agent asked if I'd be visiting this place, and due to the location directly adjacent to the airport it was my scheduled activity for the final day. Up until very recently (or perhaps until next spring), it was the largest shopping mall in the United States, with nearly twice as many stores as my local mega mall (South Coast Plaza, the third/fourth largest in the US). Granted, I have no love for shopping, so there must be another reason for me checking this place out. This is a theme park tour, so...


Yep, Mall of America houses its own theme park. Occupying 7 acres at the center of the mall, the park is completely indoors and able to operate year-round even in Minnesota's climate. Originally started by the Knott family and called Camp Snoopy, Cedar Fair sold the park in the mid-2000s due to difficulty operating the park in such a limited environment. Today, the park is known as Nickelodeon Universe, and houses two-dozen rides themed to Nicktoons past and present.


After purchasing an unlimited ride wristband with an add-on attraction, I headed to Avatar Airbender to start with what I believed to be the lowest capacity coaster at the park. Themed to the Nickelodeon show Avatar, The Last Airbender and not James Cameron's movie with a land larger than this whole park in Florida, Avatar Airbender is an Intamin Surfrider.


The ride seats a dozen riders at a time and shuttles them back and forth along a U-shaped track. The resulting ride felt halfway between a Disk'O and an Impulse coaster, with plenty of spinning on vertical spikes. It wasn't spectacular, but it was fun.


Next up was the park's other big coaster, SpongeBob SquarePants Rock Bottom Plunge. A Euro-Fighter by Gerstlauer, this one begins with a 75 ft. beyond vertical drop leading to a loop, heartline roll, and helix in quick succession.


While not as impressive as some others of the type I've experienced, the ride was fairly smooth and enjoyable.


Unfortunately, I quickly discovered that this was where I should have started my day, as the park was operating this coaster with a single eight-passenger car (it can run up to four). On a fairly busy Sunday, this meant a 30 minute wait even shortly after opening.


Quickly realizing what was in store, I crossed the park to Fairly Odd Coaster, a Gerstlauer spinner identical to two I'd ridden earlier in the trip (though this was actually the first installed by the company).


To my horror, this ride was running just two of its six cars (each of which seats only four riders), making the family-friendly coaster a 45 minute wait. Like the Euro-figher, this one was middle of the pack for the type, though probably the weakest of the three on the tour.


Three coasters down, one left to do. But first, I opted to hop on Ghost Blasters, the park's Sally shooting dark ride, as the line was nearly non-existent as I passed. This is a stock shooting dark ride, similar to the Boo Blaster rides at Cedar Fair parks but with a catchy theme song and a bit more cheese. Not spectacular by any means, but one of those rides I have a bit of a guilty pleasure for. Plus, it was nice to see a proper dark ride at this small park after several larger parks on the tour failed to feature one.


Anyway, on with the last coaster. Pepsi Orange Streak opened with the park in 1992, and as such it is integrated into the structure of the mall. This large sprawling junior coaster gives a similar vibe to Jaguar at Knott's Berry Farm, but runs smoother and includes a short dark ride segment half way through. Single train ops (no surprise) meant a 30 minute wait, but sometimes such is necessary as a credit counter.


The four coasters complete meant there was one other priority ride at the park. An indoor park is a curious place for a water ride, but Nickelodeon Universe features the Log Chute an indoor log flume and the only ride not rethemed to Nickelodeon. Instead, the ride is themed loosely to Paul Bunyan, with several indoor scenes to fill sections between the ride's two lifts and two drops. As an original attraction, the ride felt very much like Knott's Timber Mountain Log Ride, and while not quite as good it still ranks among the better log flume rides out there.


With all the must-do attractions complete and queues growing to an hour for top rides, I opted to leave the park and hunt for something to eat in the mall. One lunch later, I returned, but not for any of the park's rides. Instead, I used the add-on to experience the nearby Flyover America attraction. A flying theater very similar to Soarin', the ride is an aerial tour of many famous sites scattered across the United States. Unlike the former, this one features a full motion base on the seats, leading to a stronger flying sensation and a slightly more thrilling ride. Is it better than Soarin'? Tough to's longer and feels more like a ride, but it's also less immersive and lacks the music and scents that make Soarin' so great. I'm going to call it a draw, and I do think the film is worth seeing. Would I pay to do it again? Probably not, but I might consider the Canada film that's also an option.


With about an hour and a half until I needed to be at the airport, I tried out a few of the park's less

Replies (7)

October 31, 2019, 5:05 PM


Below are several top ten lists for coaster types and park chains on the tour. If you're curious about my rankings for anything else, leave a comment and I'll add it.

Arrow Loopers:

1. Tennessee Tornado (Dollywood)
2. Dragon Mountain (Marineland Theme Park)
3. Loch Ness Monster (Busch Gardens Williamsburg)
4. Vortex (Kings Island) R.I.P.
5. Canyon Blaster (Adventuredome)
6. Viper (Six Flags Magic Mountain)
7. Viper (Six Flags Darien Lake)
8. Demon (California's Great America)
9. Anaconda (Kings Dominion)
10. Demon (Six Flags Great America)

Arrow Mine Trains:

1. Thunderation (Silver Dollar City)
2. Runaway Mine Train (Six Flags Over Texas)
3. Road Runner Express (Six Flags Fiesta Texas)
4. Adventure Express (Kings Island)
5. Gold Rusher (Six Flags Magic Mountain)
6. Carolina Goldrusher (Carowinds)
7. River King Mine Train (Six Flags St. Louis)
8. Dahlonega Mine Train (Six Flags Over Georgia)
9. Runaway Mine Train (Six Flags Great Adventure)
10. Cedar Creek Mine Ride (Cedar Point)

B&M Inverted Coasters:

1. Alpengeist (Busch Gardens Williamsburg)
2. Flight Deck (California's Great America)
3. Montu (Busch Gardens Tampa)
4. Afterburn (Carowinds)
5. Banshee (Kings Island)
6. Dragon Challenge (Universal Studios Islands of Adventure) R.I.P.
7. Raptor (Cedar Point)
8. Patriot (Worlds of Fun)
9. Talon (Dorney Park & Wildwater Kingdom)
10. Silver Bullet (Knott's Berry Farm)

CCI Woodies:

1. Boulder Dash (Lake Compounce)
2. Shivering Timbers (Michigan's Adventure)
3. GhostRider (Knott's Berry Farm)
4. Raven (Holiday World)
5. Legend (Holiday World)
6. Cornball Express (Indiana Beach)
7. Timber Terror (Silverwood Theme Park)
8. Tremors (Silverwood Theme Park)
9. Silver Comet (Fantasy Island)
10. Boss (Six Flags St. Louis)

Gerstlauer Euro-Fighters:

1. Mystery Mine (Dollywood)
2. Dare Devil Dive (Six Flags Over Georgia)
3. SpongeBob SquarePants Rock Bottom Plunge (Nickelodeon Universe)
4. Untamed (Canobie Lake Park)
5. Tantrum (Six Flags Darien Lake)

GCI Woodies:

1. Thunderhead (Dollywood)
2. Gold Striker (California's Great America)
3. Kentucky Rumbler (Beech Bend)
4. Lightning Racer (Hersheypark)
5. Mystic Timbers (Kings Island)
6. Prowler (Worlds of Fun)
7. Renegade (Valleyfair)
8. Apocalypse the Ride (Six Flags Magic Mountain)
9. White Lightning (Fun Spot America)
10. Roar (Six Flags Discovery Kingdom) R.I.P.

Vekoma Boomerangs:

1. Bat (Canada's Wonderland)
2. Sidewinder (Hersheypark)
3. Boomerang (Worlds of Fun)
4. Flashback (Great Escape)
5. Boomerang Coast to Coaster (Six Flags Discovery Kingdom)
6. Boomerang (Elitch Gardens)
7. Boomerang (Knott's Berry Farm) R.I.P.
8. Boomerang (Six Flags Fiesta Texas)
9. Boomerang Coast to Coaster (Six Flags Darien Lake)
10. Flashback (Six Flags New England)

Vekoma SLCs:

1. Thunderhawk (Michigan's Adventure)
2. Fly the Great Nor'Easter (Morey's Piers)
3. Mind Eraser (Elitch Gardens)
4. Flight Deck (Canada's Wonderland)
5. Mind Eraser (Six Flags America)
6. Mind Eraser (Six Flags Darien Lake)
7. Kong (Six Flags Discovery Kingdom)
8. T3 (Kentucky Kingdom)
9. Riddler Revenge (Six Flags New England)
10. Ednor-L'Attaque (La Ronde)

Cedar Fair Parks:

1. Cedar Point
2. Kings Island
3. Knott's Berry Farm
4. Kings Dominion
5. Canada's Wonderland
6. Dorney Park & Wildwater Kingdom
7. Worlds of Fun
8. Carowinds
9. California's Great America
10. Valleyfair

Six Flags Parks:

1. Six Flags Magic Mountain
2. Six Flags Great Adventure
3. Six Flags Great America
4. Six Flags Fiesta Texas
5. Six Flags Over Texas
6. Six Flags Over Georgia
7. Six Flags New England
8. Six Flags St. Louis
9. Six Flags Discovery Kingdom
10. Six Flags Darien Lake

October 31, 2019, 5:12 PM

Thank you, AJ, for these amazing reports!

Edited: November 1, 2019, 1:04 PM

I felt that Renegade was a solid coaster. We happened to ride it for the first time near dusk, and while sitting in the back seat, couldn't tell whether the first drop would turn right or left. This unpredictability and relative intensity from a somewhat diminutive woodie were its strongest attributes, and propelled it into a position typically reserved for more critically acclaimed coasters.

I'm surprised the ops at Nickelodeon Universe were so spotty. We noticed some of the flat rides were running with skeleton crews, but all of the coasters were running their full compliment of trains with multiple ride ops to facilitate quick dispatches, and that was on a weekday.

Having ridden Timer Mountain Log Ride after its recent renovation, I would similarly place it above Log Chute, but it's a close race between these 2 as the best log flumes not named Splash Mountain or Dudley Do Right.

We did spend time at the Zoo, but did a hard pass on Como Town, which looked like a mediocre carnival at best. The time we spent at the Zoo and botanical garden felt a better use of time than paying individually for crummy mobile attractions. Did you by chance get to ride the carousel? It was closed when we visited, but was noted as being historic on a plaque on the exterior of the enclosure.

Also, since it sounds like you'll be in my neck of the woods next year, let me know what your schedule will be so maybe we can arrange to meet up.

November 1, 2019, 3:23 PM

>>I have decided that this will be the last trip for which I'll be writing a long format trip report, at least for US trips. Over the past few years, I've managed to visit a majority of the noteworthy parks in the United States and have chronicled many of them here. Between that, the limited time I have to work on these reports, and the relatively small readership size, it just doesn't make sense to continue them any longer.

Hypothetically speaking, if there was a pateron project, would that change the equation?

November 4, 2019, 10:51 AM

AJ. Really enjoyed reading your account about this latest journey. I also appreciate the fact that it has heightened my awareness about which parks to visit should I happen to be in those areas of the country. Sorry to hear this will be the end of your reports, but can understand how much time and effort it takes you to create them.

I also appreciate your rankings at the end of the reports. Especially the one at end of part 8. I don't always agree with all of the rankings, but I understand the subjectivity and your preferences.

I might be tempted to join your group for next year's adventure. Some of Those parks you listed I am overdue to visit or have yet to cross off my list. May even bring along my 11 year old grandson if that's OK. He rides everything and my wife is not really a coaster fan (back issues and fear of heights).

November 5, 2019, 12:49 PM

I've been to Valleyfair once, 12 years ago, and looking at your trip report and seeing your pictures to me it seemed like literally nothing about the park has changed at all.

That made me think of one thing I distinctly remembered from my visit was that they only painted the bottom of Wild Things supports near the midway and didn't go past how high up the ladder could go. That made me curious to look closely at the third picture in your trip report, I have the same picture from my visit 12 years ago and they left the ride like that! It's been over a decade and they just left the terrible paint job like that lmao.

November 6, 2019, 2:17 PM

Thanks for all the kind words, everyone! I'm glad you've all enjoyed this report.

Regarding the future, the decision was based on three things:

1. This report took four months to write due to a number of other things occupying my time (including a long weekend trip I did in October), yet it's only about 2/3 the length of last year's report which was done in less time.

2. I've now visited almost every major park in the United States and have reported on many of them over the past few years, so writing about those parks again feels a bit redundant.

3. Next summer will be super packed with both theme park and non-theme park activities, meaning there will be even less time to write than this year.

Don't worry, I will still write just won't be a day by day account of the entire trip. Instead, expect three or four parts focusing on what's new since my previous report (many of next year's parks were covered on the 2018 trip) and any of the new places I visit.

Regarding next year's trip, I am finishing an interest survey that will be posted here along with all the details I have at the moment. I'm hoping to have that up this weekend. If you think you might be interested in joining for at least a portion of the tour (or even just meeting up for a day or two), definitely give it a look once it goes up.

This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.

Park tickets

Weekly newsletter

New attraction reviews

News archive