The best and worst major refurbs at Disneyland at Walt Disney World

March 11, 2014, 11:23 AM

Looking back at the major attraction refurbishments at either the Disneyland or Walt Disney World Resorts over the past decade, which ones do you think Disney did the best job with? And which ones did you think Disney missed on?

Big Thunder's coming back from a major refurb at Disneyland this week so I'm working on a piece comparing some of the major refurbs at DL and WDW and would love to hear some readers' thoughts.


Replies (7)

March 11, 2014, 1:01 PM

The best one, I hear, is Space Mountain at DL. I never went on it before 2005, but on my visit last year, I was surprised how smooth and fun it was compared to MK's. The worst has got to be Matterhorn. Again, never went on it pre-refurb, but the post-refurb is so painful and jerky that it can't possibly be the classic people talk about. Even my thrill junkie brother didn't want to try that one again.

March 11, 2014, 4:51 PM

Best Disneyland refurb is the Timon parking lot.

March 11, 2014, 4:55 PM

Dumbo's refurb had me nervous at first but is now my favorite, and I sorta don't like the new Pirate's of the Carribean mermaid scene only because it makes you feel like something exciting is going to happen but it is really just a boring gap with faint mermaid singing.

March 12, 2014, 7:00 AM

Worst 3 at Disneyland:

1) Any Indiana Jones refurbishment, because even when it comes back up, half the effects still don't work. Bonus points to the recent one that replaced James Earl Jones with a screeching diva.

2) Pirates of the Caribbean: Take a beloved classic, ruin a dark, atmospheric transition with a cheap projection on a mist screen (because that worked so well with Indiana Jones?) replace the captain with an unconvincing Barbosa animatronics, and force an awkward storyline where you could previously imagine an elegant, vague one. What next, a Sanka Coffee animatronic on the Matterhorn?

3) Speaking of the Matterhorn, not only have you lost the ability to hold your date or significant other close, you'll now probably also lose your dental fillings and your tailbone as well.

Best 3 at Disneyland

1) Old Matterhorn refurb. Yes the mountain makes both the best and worst lists. This nomination is for the one that filled a hollow, unconvincing wooden interior with beautiful caves and grottoes, a yeti, and an increased capacity. Bravo

2) Space Mountain: cleaned up, smoothed-out track, new soundtrack that fit perfectly, and a dramatic reduction of the light levels was exactly what this ride needed.

3) Snow White: Amazing what good quality mapped projections can do to take a simple dark ride and bring it into the 21st century while keeping the original appeal intact. The projections could have come off as cheap or gimmicky, but instead they were an understated enhancement that simply improved the show.

Edited: March 14, 2014, 5:14 AM

Top 3 refurbishments at Walt Disney World (in no particular order):

1) Updating the Safari with more animals and less poacher chasing.

2) Star Tours to the new random ride.

3) Spaceship Earth with the choose your own ending

Worst 3 ride refurbishments in Walt Disney World:

1) Journey into Imagination (first update)

2) From Alien to Stitch's Great Escape

3) Living with the Land (I miss the song)

March 15, 2014, 12:33 PM

Thank you for the feedback, everyone. That post I was writing is up now!

March 15, 2014, 4:49 PM

Most definitely agree with the last opinion comment. What was WDW thinking when they ditched Alien Encounter?

This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.

Park tickets

Weekly newsletter

New attraction reviews

News archive